Grief can hit hard, and then the paperwork shows up. If the will you were handed feels off or out of character for your loved one, questions are normal. At Jordan & White, LLC, we have 13 years of helping Massachusetts families with probate, estate planning, and real estate matters, and we know how personal these disputes feel. Our goal here is simple: give you a clear picture of who can contest a will, the timing rules, valid legal grounds, and what the process looks like from start to finish.
Who Has the Right to Contest a Will in Massachusetts?
Not everyone can challenge a will. The law requires “standing,” which means you have a real stake in the outcome. Without standing, the court will not hear the case, even if your concerns feel justified to you.
People who usually have standing include the following groups:
- Spouse.
- Devisees named in the will submitted for probate.
- Devisees in a previous will.
- Legal heirs of the estate under Massachusetts intestate succession.
- Creditors of the estate with recognized claims.
If you fit one of these categories, the next step is timing. Deadlines can be short, and missing them can end your case before it starts.
Time Limits for Contesting a Will
If you have concerns about a will’s validity, talk with a will attorney right away. The clock starts soon after the case hits probate court, and the rules differ based on informal or formal probate.
For informal probate, objections can be raised within three years from the date of death or within 12 months from the informal allowance of the will, whichever is later. Formal probate runs on tighter deadlines and uses a court notice called a “citation.”
The citation lists two critical dates: the Return Date is the last day to file an appearance to let the court know you plan to object. Within 30 days after the Return Date, you must file a written Affidavit of Objections that lays out your factual and legal reasons, or your rights are likely gone.
| Massachusetts Will Contest Deadlines | ||||
| Probate Type | First Step to Object | Appearance Deadline | Affidavit of Objections | Notes |
| Informal Probate | File petition to contest | N, A | N, A | File within three years of death, or within 12 months from informal allowance, whichever is later. |
| Formal Probate | File appearance in the same case | By the Return Date on the citation | Within 30 days after the Return Date | Missing either date likely waives the right to contest. |
Courts enforce these dates strictly. If you suspect issues, act quickly to protect your rights.
Valid Legal Grounds for Contesting a Will in Massachusetts
Being upset about who gets what is not enough. A will contest argues that the document submitted to the court is legally invalid. Below are the most common grounds that Massachusetts courts recognize.
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
This claim says the person who signed the will did not have the mental capacity required to make one. To have capacity, the testator must have understood, at the time of signing, the purpose of the will, the nature of their assets, and who their legal heirs were. The Supreme Judicial Court explained these points in O’Rourke vs. Hunter, 446 Mass. 814.
Capacity is judged at the moment of execution. Someone can have good and bad days, so the focus is on the specific signing date, not a general diagnosis alone.
Undue Influence
Undue influence means someone pressured or manipulated the testator into making choices they would not have made on their own. The Appeals Court discussed these claims in Paine v. Sullivan, a case involving a frail elder and drastic changes to a will late in life.
If the influencer had a fiduciary relationship with the testator and benefitted from the new will, the burden can shift to the influencer to show the absence of undue influence. Red flags include isolation, control over money or care, sudden changes in distributions, and a beneficiary facing money troubles.
- Control over the testator’s daily life, finances, or medical care.
- Cutting off contact with family or friends.
- Large gifts or new terms that favor the influencer without a clear reason.
Fraud
Fraud covers lies or trickery that leads the testator to sign a will with terms they did not truly approve. One example is the testator signing a document they thought was something else. Another is false information fed to the testator about people or property to steer the will’s terms.
Evidence can include witness statements, conflicting documents, and inconsistencies in how the will was prepared or presented for signature.
Forgery
Forgery alleges the signature is not the testator’s. Questioned signatures, handwriting analysis, and testimony from witnesses at the signing often become central proof.
Improper Execution
Massachusetts sets formal steps for a valid will. The will must be in writing, signed by the testator or by someone directed to sign in the testator’s presence, and witnessed by two adults who observe the signing.
If the signing did not meet these formalities, the will can fail. Execution problems can be simple, like only one witness, and still matter.
Revocation/Subsequent Will
Sometimes, a new will replaces the old one. Other times, a person revokes a will by physical act combined with intent, like tearing it up after giving clear instructions. Proving revocation usually requires strong proof, such as a later will or statements from people who heard the testator’s decision.
If you believe an earlier valid will exists, locating it fast can change the entire case.
The Massachusetts Will Contest Process
Once you file objections, the case proceeds much like other civil lawsuits. The personal representative, often called the executor, must defend the will that was submitted to the court. Both sides gather facts, interview witnesses, and request documents.
Here is a simple view of what usually happens next:
- Discovery and evidence exchange, including medical records, emails, drafts, and witness testimony.
- Talks about settlement outside of court to see if the dispute can be resolved.
- If no agreement, a judge or jury decides the issues at a hearing or trial.
- If the contest succeeds, the will is thrown out, and the court looks for a prior valid will or applies intestate succession rules.
- If the contest fails, probate continues under the submitted will.
Each case turns on facts. Small details, like who arranged the lawyer or who was present at the signing, can make a big difference.
Do you need help contesting a Massachusetts Will?
Questions about a will are stressful, and you do not need to sort them out alone. Feel free to call us at 978-744-2811 or reach us through our Contact Us page to talk about your situation. At Jordan & White, LLC, we focus on protecting your interests and moving your case forward with care and steady communication.
Download the Estate Planning Launch Pad for those wanting to get organized.
Schedule a Great Life Discovery Session™ for those just getting started.
Book a Keeping It Great Check-In™ for those who already have a plan and want to review or adjust it.
If something about the will just does not add up, let us take a look. We welcome your questions and can step in quickly to meet deadlines and build the record needed for court. One call can bring clarity, and that helps you and your family take the next right step.